Cats Afraid of Aluminum Foil
Last Updated: November 1, 2024
Last Updated: November 1, 2024
Last Updated: November 1, 2024
Last Updated: October 31, 2024
If you’ve ever tried to use a virtual address from a service like Regus, Anytime Mailbox, or a co-working space to get a pin on Google Maps, you’ve probably noticed it doesn’t work anymore. You can still use these addresses for “service-area” businesses, but they won’t get you that coveted map pin. So, why the change? It all goes back to the way Google’s verification process has evolved over the years. If you’ve felt the frustration of each new layer of verification, you’re not alone — and understanding this history helps explain why today’s methods are more thorough and harder to bypass.
In the beginning, Google required no verification at all. Users could put together a map listing, and after a cursory review (if that), it went live. Google also introduced a tool called Map Maker that let users make real-time changes to listings. With so little oversight, businesses used virtual addresses, while spammers and competitors created fake profiles, edited legitimate listings, and flooded the system with inaccurate data. Over time, this mess of invalid listings threatened Google’s reliability, leading them to evolve to phone verifications and eventually close down Map Maker altogether.
Google’s first real attempt at verification came in the form of phone calls and text messages. The idea was to link listings to a specific phone number tied to the location’s country. This method initially worked well enough and continued to allow virtual addresses to pass. Unfortunately, people quickly found workarounds, using Google Voice or burner phones to verify addresses, even if they weren’t real business locations. Google tried limiting the number of times a phone number could be used in a six-month period, but this didn’t stop determined users and spammers from bypassing the system.
Google’s next step was to send verification postcards by mail. These postcards contained a unique code to be entered for listing verification. While this slowed down some bad actors, it still allowed virtual addresses and co-working spaces to pass as legitimate locations. Google’s hope was that businesses with physical addresses would find this process easy, while the hurdles would stop spammers. However, some users started using tricks like setting up mail forwarding at the post office — requesting a change of address to route postcards from vacant lots or co-working spaces to their actual location. While it was more challenging, these tactics allowed virtual addresses to keep working for most users. It was also expensive since it required Google to use labor from high-cost areas like the USA, print physical postcards, pay for postage, and physically ship them out.
After postcards failed to curb all the spam, Google introduced a video upload requirement. Now, users had to record and submit a video of their storefront, giving Google’s team visual proof that the business existed at the stated location. This change marked the beginning of the end for virtual addresses on the map, as users couldn’t easily fake a storefront at a virtual address or mailbox location. Virtual addresses, which had previously been a viable, albeit tricky, option, started to hit serious obstacles. If Google’s team had any doubts after reviewing the video, they could ask for additional documents, like utility bills or official business registrations, adding further scrutiny that made it harder to use virtual addresses.
Google’s most recent (and so far most foolproof) method of verification is live video calls. This approach takes video verification up a notch by requiring a real-time video call where a Google rep can direct you to show specific parts of your business location, verifying you’re where you claim to be. This new process reduces the friction introduced by the requirement for documents and speeds up the verification process overall. They may ask you to walk around, show signage, or verify other location-specific details on the spot. Since it’s nearly impossible to fake this in a virtual address or co-working space, virtual offices have become unusable for pin verification, even if you can use them for service-area businesses.
Every change Google has made has been a response to an issue impacting the reliability of map listings, and let’s be honest, an effort to cut costs. If spammy and fake listings overrun the platform, users might look to alternative services. As spammers and businesses got more inventive with workarounds, Google had to keep evolving its process, tightening up from unverified listings to today’s real-time video calls.
It’s worth noting that there are still exceptions to the official “rules” for these. In certain edge cases, you may be required to do a verification by phone or mail, for example. The intent of this article is to document the evolution, not to be an exhaustive list of all possibilities.
What new verification method might be on the horizon? Only time will tell, but it’s clear that Google will keep adapting as long as people find ways around the rules. It might feel like an endless loop, but it’s all for a good cause — to keep map listings accurate, useful, and trustworthy for businesses and customers alike.
Now you know why each step came about and why virtual addresses have fallen out of favor for map pins. Hopefully, you feel better prepared for whatever Google rolls out next!
Last Updated: October 25, 2024
Last Updated: October 25, 2024
Recently, a client reached out to us with a puzzling Google Business Profile (GBP) issue. His team had been regularly sharing the Google review link with customers to acquire reviews, which is, of course, a critical part of every business’ online strategy these days. The listing was live and fully visible to anyone searching for the business, so from the outside, everything looked fine.
However, there was a hidden problem: when customers clicked on the link to leave reviews, they simply couldn’t. Google was actively preventing them from leaving reviews, but our client had no clue this was happening—there were no warnings or notifications from Google. He only learned of the issue when a customer notified him that the review link wasn’t working.
Without any alerts or notifications from Google, it wasn’t immediately obvious what was wrong. Our team dove into the details, exploring every potential cause. After some careful troubleshooting and digging, we uncovered the root of the issue: the business had been misclassified by Google. Although the listing itself was live and customers could see it, the misclassification blocked the ability to leave reviews, a fairly rare and challenging problem to identify.
Below is what the GBP notice looked like for users. It just reads “Posting is currently turned off.”
At first, it seemed strange that Google would block reviews, but as we researched, it made more sense. Referring to these cases as “posting restrictions,” Google restricts reviews for certain types of entities and in certain situations. Some businesses, like police stations, can no longer receive reviews, while locations such as polling places have reviews turned off temporarily around election times. When fraud or abuse is detected against a particular location, reviews may also be disabled on a case-by-case basis. This process isn’t always transparent, so it can be hard to pinpoint the exact cause. You can read more about their policy governing this issue on their website.
Once we nailed down the cause, it was time to act. We knew we had to appeal directly to Google to reclassify the business under the correct category, which would reinstate the ability to leave reviews. Because we’re familiar with the appeals process and the best practices for GBP management, we moved quickly to file the appeal, ensuring Google had the information it needed to resolve the issue. Within just a few days, the review function was restored and our client could once again collect those invaluable customer reviews.
This experience is a good reminder to regularly check your Google Business Profile, especially if you rely on reviews for customer engagement. The client in this case had no idea there was a problem—without that customer’s heads-up, the issue might have gone unnoticed for months.
To stay on top of these issues, periodically check your GBP to make sure everything works as expected. Or, if you want to be completely sure your profile is in safe hands, consider working with a pro. Our team is here to monitor, maintain, and optimize your GBP to prevent these hidden problems from disrupting your business.
If you’re dealing with this issue, please reach out so we can help you resolve it. You can even sign up online by going to our Google Business Profile Rescue page.
Prospect Genius
279 Troy Rd
Ste 9 #102
Rensselaer, NY 12144
Mon – Fri: 9am – 6pm ET
(800) 689-1273
hello@prospectgenius.com
Our passion is helping small businesses thrive. It’s why we get out of bed every day. Too many business owners are cheated and lied to every day so we see it as our duty to be a beacon of truth, a safe harbor, in an often unscrupulous industry.
Just 2 failed attempts at reinstatement and your listing is gone forever! Luckily, we have a nearly 100% success rate!!